Prehistoric club-shaped symbol
P-sign in paleolithic cave art
CONTENTS
In prehistoric art, a "claviform sign" is a relatively common abstract symbol used in both cave painting and rock engravings.
It is a club-shaped pictograph, sometimes described as a vertical "P-sign". It is found in groups as well as singletons.
According to Genevieve von Petzinger, a leading expert on non-figurative imagery during the era of Upper Paleolithic art, it is one of only 32 abstract signs to be used in cave art between 40,000 and 10,000 BC.
Claviforms are present in twenty-three prehistoric caves in France - roughly 16 percent of the total. More common cave signs include: Lines (72%), Open-Angles (42%), Ovals (29%), and Quadrangles (19%).
According to Petzinger, French caves that have "claviform symbols" include:
"Claviform signs" first appeared in France during the Solutrean era (20,000-15,000 BC) and quickly gained in popularity. For example, 12.1% of Solutrean sites had claviforms, compared to 23% in the Magdalenian (15,000-10,000 BC), rising to 25% in the Late Magdalenian.
According to Petzinger, its absence until the Solutrean era suggests the sign was developed elsewhere during the Aurignacian or Gravettian eras (40,000-20,000 BC), before its take-up in France.
This opinion was confirmed in 2012, following Uranium/Thorium (U/Th) dating tests at Altamira Cave in Cantabria, Spain, where a large red claviform was dated to 34,160 BC - the oldest known example in Franco-Cantabrian cave art.
Other Spanish caves which contain this sign, include Pindal Cave in the Asturias, as well as Cullalvera Cave and La Pasiega Cave in Cantabria. Note that La Pasiega is home to the world's oldest scalariform image, dating to 62,000 BC.
For more about the chronology of paleolithic cave signs, see: Prehistoric Art Timeline (from 540,000 BC).
For years, archaeologists thought that claviform distribution was overwhelmingly centred upon sites in the Ariège region of the Pyrénées.
Today, while this area remains an important area for this sign type, there are others, including: the Ardèche/Gard region, home to three out of four sites in the Solutrean; and the Dordogne/Lot region, a major centre for the sign type during the Magdalenian.
Although, as one might expect, there is no hard evidence as to the meaning and significance of non-figurative cave signs, theories continue to abound.
One especially interesting attempt to decipher such signs, like claviforms, is the Cave Script Translation Project - an independent research project that interprets prehistoric ideomorphs using ancient Chinese characters, and other eclectic datasets.
One example that appears on the CSTP website (see reference, below) involves the drawing of a pregnant horse - covered in a series of more than a dozen claviform signs - taken from Trois Frères Cave, and dated to about 13,500 BC.
According to Lynn Fawcett of the Cave Script Translation Project, the size of the horse's belly and its raised tail indicates that she will foal soon.
Turning to the P-shaped claviforms, Fawcett explains they resemble archaic versions of Kangxi radical number 36, xī, meaning sunset or night.
There are 12 of these xī-like symbols, possibly indicating that the series is an ideographic representation of the hours of darkness.
In addition, there is another sign, which resembles Kangxi radical number 2, gǔn or gěn, which means 'to drop'.
Conclusion: the picture, combined with the signs, is telling us that the foal will be born in the hours of darkness before dawn.
See also: What is the Meaning of Cave art?
For details of other cave symbols, see the following articles:
(1)"Making the Abstract Concrete: The Place of Geometric Signs in French Upper Paleolithic Parietal Art." (2005) (Thesis) Genevieve von Petzinger. University of Victoria, Canada.
(2) "U-Series Dating of Paleolithic Art in 11 Caves in Spain." A. W. G. Pike et al. Science 336, 1409 (2012).
(3) Cave Script Translation Project. cavescript.org